Supreme Court Leaves Fourth Circuit Decision Limiting Redevelopment Takings Challenges Intact

Posted

For developers and investors, a lawsuit challenging the government’s acquisition of project land can put far more than litigation costs at stake. It can complicate financing, cloud a transaction and threaten the schedule on which a project’s economics depend. A recent Fourth Circuit decision illustrates why an early assessment of the property rights asserted by the challengers can be central to protecting the project.

On November 9, 2026, the U.S. Supreme Court denied review in Poppleton Now Community Association, Inc. v. La Cite Development, LLC, leaving intact a published Fourth Circuit decision requiring dismissal of a constitutional takings challenge to a Baltimore redevelopment project. The plaintiffs—a neighborhood association and three couples who owned property adjacent to the project area—sued developer defendants, the City of Baltimore, and related public entities and officials. The Fourth Circuit held that the plaintiffs’ alleged harm from the project did not permit them to challenge the taking of others’ property without alleging a protected property interest in the property taken.

Tony Phillips led the Pillsbury team representing the developer defendants throughout the case, including arguing the Fourth Circuit appeal on behalf of all defendants. The defense focused on a fundamental defect in the plaintiffs’ constitutional challenge: They alleged no protected property interest in the property taken. That strategy secured dismissal of the takings claim at the pleading stage and offers practical guidance for developers, capital providers and public entities facing challenges to redevelopment and land assembly.

The Poppleton Redevelopment Dispute
The case arose from Baltimore’s agreement with a private developer to redevelop approximately 13.8 acres in the Poppleton neighborhood. Under the Land Disposition and Development Agreement, the City undertook to acquire properties within the project area, including through eminent domain, for transfer to the developer in phases as redevelopment progressed.

In 2024, three married couples and a neighborhood association filed suit in federal district court, alleging that the City’s property acquisitions lacked a constitutionally sufficient public use and that project delays and site conditions had reduced neighboring property values and interfered with residents’ enjoyment of their homes. None alleged a protected property interest in the property taken through eminent domain. Because the case was decided at the pleading stage, the court considered the plaintiffs’ allegations without making factual findings.

Critically, the individual plaintiffs did not allege that the government had taken their property, physically or through regulation. Nor did the complaint allege that the association or its members owned property that had been taken.

The district court dismissed the complaint. On appeal, the plaintiffs pursued their takings and Maryland private nuisance claims, along with their request for declaratory relief. The Fourth Circuit agreed that the claims before it could not proceed in federal court, while changing the legal grounds for dismissal.

The Property Right Determines the Takings Claim
The Fourth Circuit drew a distinction between having a sufficient injury to enter federal court and having the property right necessary to prevail on a takings claim.

The plaintiffs alleged that the redevelopment project had reduced the value of their neighboring properties. Those allegations were sufficient, at the pleading stage, to establish Article III standing. But they did not supply the missing element of the constitutional claim. As the court explained: “A protected property interest in the taken property is an essential element of a takings claim.”

Because the plaintiffs alleged no such interest, their takings claim failed as a matter of law. The Fourth Circuit therefore directed dismissal for failure to state a claim under Rule 12(b)(6), replacing the district court’s dismissal for lack of standing. See No. 25-1770, slip op. at 9-14 (4th Cir. May 4, 2026).

For project defendants, the distinction matters. Alleged economic harm may establish standing without establishing a constitutional violation. Examining whose property was taken, what interest each plaintiff held and what governmental action allegedly affected that interest can identify a dispositive issue before discovery begins.

The decision did not resolve whether the challenged acquisitions satisfied the public-use requirement. It resolved the threshold merits question of whether these plaintiffs had alleged the property interest necessary to pursue that challenge. The Supreme Court’s denial of certiorari leaves that ruling intact.

Practical Steps for Developers and Capital Providers
The decision suggests several steps for assessing and managing challenges to redevelopment projects:

  • Examine each plaintiff’s property interest at the outset. Match the complaint’s allegations to title records, acquisition documents and condemnation history. The relevant inquiry extends beyond whether someone opposes the project or claims financial harm to whether that person holds the right the asserted cause of action protects.
  • Evaluate standing and the merits separately. Poppleton demonstrates that an alleged loss of property value may support federal jurisdiction while leaving a fatal defect in the underlying claim. A defense strategy should address both when appropriate. Identifying either defect early on can create an opportunity for dismissal without discovery into the project’s full history.
  • Assess the consequences for the transaction. Developers and lenders should determine which claims could affect title, approvals or the ability to proceed, and which principally concern damages or site conditions. That assessment can inform financing conditions, reserves and decisions about whether particular work can continue during litigation.
  • Maintain the project record through delays and amendments. Preserve acquisition records, development agreements and amendments, along with documentation of performance and responsibility for site maintenance. An early constitutional defense does not eliminate the need to address separately any viable contractual or state-law exposure.
  • Describe litigation outcomes precisely. A dismissal on the merits, a jurisdictional dismissal and a dismissal without prejudice have different consequences. Financing and transaction disclosures should identify what the court resolved and what remains open. In Poppleton, the constitutional challenge failed because the plaintiffs lacked the required property interest; the nuisance claim was left for possible pursuit in state court.

Protecting the Project Through Focused Litigation
Poppleton illustrates the commercial value of identifying a dispositive legal issue early. A challenge framed around the tumultuous history and undesirable consequences of a redevelopment project may nevertheless turn on a specific question about the rights of the plaintiffs who brought it. Resolving that question can narrow the dispute and help developers and investors make informed decisions about the capital and work still at stake.

Pillsbury represents developers and investors in disputes involving land assembly, public-private development agreements and project delays. To discuss a challenge affecting your project’s financing, schedule or ability to proceed, contact Tony Phillips.